<
Toby's Jewelry
A note from Toby's Jewelry
Gold prices are at
record highs.

Now is the perfect time to sell. Walk in to Toby's in Hartsdale for the highest offer in Westchester. Free evaluation, no obligation — walk out with cash.

And we have exciting news — a brand new online experience is launching soon, with curated collections, lab diamond jewelry, and much more. Stay tuned.

Mon – Thu
10am – 6pm
Friday
10am – 12pm
Saturday
CLOSED
Sunday
11am – 4pm
Get Directions Call Now
1 S Central Ave · Hartsdale, NY 10530 · (914) 288-8066
Skip to content

Toby's Jewelry

Cart

Your cart is empty

Signup for our newsletter

Describe what your customers will receive when subscribing to your newsletter.

Westchester's Most Trusted Gold Buyer Since 1980

We pay top dollar for your gold.

Get a Free Quote

46 Years

Serving Westchester

12 Neighborhoods

Nextdoor Favorite

4.5 Stars

Yelp and Google Reviews

10,000+ Designs

Custom pieces created

Now available at Toby's

Lab-grown diamonds are chemically identical to mined diamonds. IGI certified. Under $499 for a 1ct top-quality stone — up to 70% more affordable. Impossible to detect even by most diamond testers.

Explore Lab Diamonds

Custom Jewelry Design

Your vision, handcrafted.

Bring us a sketch, a photo, a stone, or just an idea — our team will design and create a one-of-a-kind piece built around you. 10,000+ custom designs created for Westchester families. Starting from $500.

What our customers say

Trusted by Westchester for generations.

Best in Westchester for buying gold — by far and away. The staff was great and I sent many people there who were equally satisfied.

Bob G.

Same great experience 10 years later. My first visit was for my wedding in 2015. Truly one of a kind — there is no other store like this in Westchester.

Alexandra K.

Custom pieces that are incredibly beautiful. Repair service is top notch and extremely reasonably priced.

Anne A.